From analogue to digital: methods, costs and what really matters

From analogue to digital: anyone who wants to understand how analogue signals, photos or films are turned into durable digital data needs more than a product recommendation. They need the right method for their medium, realistic cost expectations and clarity on when a DIY approach is enough and when a professional can protect what is irreplaceable.

What does “from analogue to digital” actually mean in technical terms?

The term describes the conversion of information stored in analogue form into digital data. Continuous signals or optical information like sound waves, light intensity, magnetic tracks on a tape or image information on film and paper, are sampled, translated into numerical values and then stored as a file.

Sampling and quantisation: the two core stages

Sampling: The analogue signal is sampled at regular intervals. For audio, this is commonly 44,100 measurements per second (44.1 kHz for CD standard) or 96,000 Hz for professional productions. The more frequently the signal is sampled, the more accurately the original can be reconstructed.
Quantisation: Each sampled momentary value is rounded to a discrete digital value. The bit depth determines the number of possible levels: at 16 bit, 65,536 gradations are available, which corresponds to CD standard. At 24 bit, there are more than 16 million levels. This corresponds to professional studio quality and provides dynamic range reserves that are crucial for editing and post-processing.

Which analogue media does this apply to in practice?

In everyday use, “from analogue to digital” can refer to very different source materials:

• Audio (vinyl records, cassettes, reel-to-reel tapes): the signal is stored as a mechanical groove or magnetic track
• Photos (negatives, slides, photo prints): depending on the material, the information is contained in dyes, silver image components or the reflected or transmitted image layer.
• Video (VHS, S-VHS, Video 8, Hi8, Betamax, Super 8): analogue magnetic tapes or film strips
• Documents (paper, files, drawings): light intensity is captured by a scanner

Each medium has different requirements in terms of hardware, software and post-processing. There is no universal method.

Methods compared: which technology is suitable for which medium?

A/D converters for audio

For converting vinyl records or cassettes into digital audio files, a simple external USB audio input, known as an A/D converter, is often enough at the most basic level and is available from around £20. These devices connect the analogue line output of a cassette deck or a record player with an integrated phono preamp to the computer. With classic turntables, an additional phono preamp is usually required. Recording is done using free software like Audacity. For better results, USB audio interfaces with 24-bit converters, clean level handling and the lowest possible self-noise are recommended. Simple 24-bit interfaces are available from around £50; solid mid-range devices are often between £80 and £150, while higher-quality interfaces for more demanding archiving or post-processing usually start from around £150.

Scanners for photos, slides and negatives

Home scanners today achieve resolutions of 1,200 to 4,800 dpi, but it’s the optical resolution, not the interpolated one, that really matters. For paper photos worth archiving, experts recommend at least 600 dpi. For 35mm slides and negatives, at least 2,400 dpi is advisable; for high-quality archiving or large-format prints, 3,200 to 4,000 dpi (or even higher) is often used, depending on the film quality, sharpness of the original and intended use. For medium-format negatives, a lower dpi value can often be sufficient than for 35mm film due to the larger film area. For high-quality archiving, however, higher resolutions are useful here too, depending on the desired output size and level of detail.

Anyone who wants to convert slides to digital or convert negatives to digital should bear in mind that inexpensive flatbed scanners without a transparency unit are unsuitable for transparent originals. Dedicated film scanners such as the Plustek OpticFilm 8200i are specified by the manufacturer with an optical resolution of 7,200 dpi. However, how much detail is actually usable also depends on film quality, focus, scanner optics and workflow. The purchase is usually only worthwhile for larger quantities or regular use.

Video digitisation takes time

VHS, Video 8 and similar formats cannot be digitised faster than in real time: a 90-minute tape therefore requires at least 90 minutes of transfer time. You need a functioning video recorder, a video converter (USB grabbers from around £15, professional devices from around £150) and recording software. The critical point: many VHS tapes from the 1980s and 1990s may already have mould, tape tears, sticky sections or other signs of ageing. In addition, dirty or incorrectly adjusted video recorders can reduce playback quality and, in extreme cases, damage the tape.

Costs: DIY vs professional digitisation

The question “How much does it cost to convert from analogue to digital?” depends heavily on the medium and the desired quality:

Quality factors that determine success or failure

Signal-to-noise ratio and self-noise

In audio digitisation, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the A/D converter is decisive. Cheap USB converters can limit recording quality through self-noise, poor level handling or inferior components. Higher-quality interfaces offer more headroom and avoid additional interference. With vinyl records, however, the actual quality also depends heavily on the record itself, the cartridge, the phono preamp and the setup.

Dust, scratches and digital restoration

Analogue originals are rarely perfectly preserved. Dust on slides creates bright spots in the scan, while scratches on negatives become black lines. Many professional film scanners use infrared dust correction, such as Digital ICE or similar processes, to detect and digitally reduce dust and scratches on suitable colour negatives and colour slides. However, this technology does not work, or works only to a limited extent, with traditional black-and-white films, Kodachrome material and paper prints. Most entry-level devices do not have this function at all.

File formats for long-term archiving

The target file format determines usability in 20 years’ time:

• Audio: WAV (uncompressed) or FLAC (losslessly compressed) for archiving; MP3 only for access copies
• Photo/negative/slide: TIFF (uncompressed) as the master format; JPEG for sharing and web use
• Video: MP4 is suitable for access copies. For archiving or post-processing, high-quality master formats such as ProRes, FFV1/MKV or JPEG 2000/MXF are better suited.

Proprietary formats used by individual scanner software should generally be avoided.

Step by step: from analogue to digital at home

Common mistakes in DIY digitisation and how to avoid them

Choosing too low a resolution

The most common mistake is scanning a slide at 300 dpi because “that is enough for photos”. Slides, however, have an information density that is only fully captured from around 2,400 dpi upwards. For high-quality archiving or larger outputs, 3,200 to 4,000 dpi or more can be useful. The result at 300 dpi may look acceptable on small screens, but when printed at A4 size or larger, details that were present in the original are missing. This decision cannot be reversed without scanning the original again.

Worn playback devices damage the original

Cassette decks and VHS recorders with dirty heads or faulty tape guidance not only produce poor quality, but in extreme cases can also mechanically damage tapes. Mouldy cassettes should not simply be played, as they can contaminate the device and put other media at risk. Anyone who takes an old device out of the cellar and uses it straight away risks losing the only copy of an irreplaceable document. Before any use, the heads should be cleaned and the tape path checked.

JPEG as the master format

JPEG uses lossy compression. Every time it is saved again, the quality deteriorates slightly but measurably. Anyone who saves scanned photos directly as JPEG, then later adjusts brightness or contrast and saves them again, loses image quality with every step. The TIFF original remains preserved as a lossless source file as long as it is not overwritten. Edits should therefore always be made to copies.

When is professional help worthwhile?

DIY digitisation works for simple media in good condition. But as soon as it involves converting cine films to digital, heavily used VHS tapes, mould on cassettes or large quantities of slides to digitise, the effort quickly outweighs the benefit of doing it yourself. MEDIAFIX digitises analogue media using professional hardware, careful post-processing and a quality-assured workflow, protecting memories that could be permanently lost through a single mistake.
MEDIAFIX has experience from over 268 million digitised media items.

Do you have questions about digitising your media?

Our customer service team will be happy to help: 020 3904438-0

Digitise your analogue media now

Frequently asked questions